Zoey Miller (Josephine Langford), a brilliant computer science student, believes she has the intricacies of love all mapped out. However, her life takes an unexpected turn when Zach (Drew Starkey), a renowned college soccer star, suffers from amnesia and mistakenly identifies Zoey as his girlfriend. As she grapples with revealing the truth, she encounters Zach's cousin, Miles (Archie Renaux), and discovers they share a unique bond. While maintaining the charade with Zach, Zoey finds herself torn between two hearts, pushing her to face her innermost fears and make a heart-wrenching decision.